Keto Magic Cookies

Keto Magic Cookies

Keto Magic Cookies
Delicious and easy Keto Magic Cookies

This weeks recipe is a Keto Magic Cookies!  These little mini cookies are simple to make and delicious.  With minimal ingredients need and minimal baking time.  These are sure to cure your sweet tooth.

Keto Magic Cookies
Delicious and easy to make Keto Magic Cookies


So magic can be a tricky thing….. Magicians may pull a rabbit from an empty hat, make some things seem to disappear, Or transform a red silk handkerchief into a green silk one.

So what makes these cookies “magical”….the lack of flour, was the original reason.

Coconut dream bars. Magic cookie bars. Hello Dolly bars. You’ve probably seen these classic treats at bake sales, holiday parties, and potlucks over the years, or maybe they were popular in your family traditions.  But originally, they tend to crumble when cut, thanks to a thin graham cracker crust, and topped with gobs of super-sweetened coconut, sweetened condensed milk and chocolate chips, they had a cloying bite that tended to be too much for even the sweetest tooth!

This version starts with a simpler set of keto friendly ingredients. It’s baked with eggs, a bit of coconut oil, and some butter, which makes it pleasantly dense and chewy. It also means it holds up nicely to the toppings.

The end result is a just right sweet and delicious cookie… made bite-sized in my version,  that’s almost impossible to stop at just one. This recipe is also perfect if you need a simple dessert to throw together when you’re short on time.

Now, quite honestly I struggled with these. My original reference was a classic food site, the directions were not thoroughly clear, and I ended up with, runny, spreading globs of goo…. Thankfully, this doesn’t need to happen to you because I have perfected the ideal circumstances for the perfect bite sized chewy nuggets of goodness.


So even if you see those delightful golden plump cookies when googling images of keto magic cookies, it’s very difficult to get these cookies to hold their shape without some kind of molding vessel. Most cookies you see have been cut and doctored….”sleight- of hand”, if I may use a magic term. Lol.

Using a muffin tin, silicone mold, or baking dish is essential with these cookies in achieving a solid moldable cookie. These do not do well at all made in traditional cookie form.

Next, using only a small amount of coconut oil, assures that there is not excessive oil runoff.

You want high-quality tasting, oven roasted nuts, smooth sugar free chips, and fresh unsweetened coconut, since you will be tasting all of these ingredients front and center. but absolutely feel free to use different nuts, chopped milk chocolate, or any other type of yummy sugar free sweet in these magical keto cookies. Whatever your family enjoys.

It is absolutely essential, no CRITICAL that these cookies be allowed to cool at room temperature before attempting to cut or remove them.
At least 30 to 45 minutes should be allotted for this process.

Following these tips will ensure you have a “magical” experience making these treats.

Keto Magic Cookies in Silicone Tray
Keto Magic Cookies in Silicone Tray this makes these a lot easier to make.


Well this recipe was great, but certainly a challenge to perfect.  I applaud Sarah for her persistence in trying to perfect this recipe.  I personally am not a big coconut fan.  But the combination of the chocolate chips, and pecans make these a delicious little bite full and I don’t mind the coconut.  They remind me of little Almond Joy bars.  It’s hard to not eat too many of these, so be warned.  We hope you enjoy these easy to make cookies.

Don’t forget to subscribe to our blog, if you haven’t already.  We plan on releasing keto recipes that will be exclusive for blog subscribers.  Also feel free to share this recipe with family and friends!

For a detailed cooking demonstration check out the video over on YouTube, and if you like these types of recipes consider subscribing to our YouTube channel.

Get our free Keto Quick Start Guide

Keto Quick Start Guide

Here is a companion blog post to get the best results from our Keto Quick Start Guide

Keto Magic Cookie Fresh Pin
Delicious, simple to make Keto Magic Cookies
Keto Magic Cookies
Print Pin
3 from 12 votes

Keto Magic Cookies

These little mini cookies are simple to make and delicious.  With minimal ingredients need and minimal baking time.  These are sure to cure your sweet tooth.
Course Dessert, keto snacks, low snack
Cuisine American
Keyword easy keto snacks, easy low carb snacks, keto snacks
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Servings 24 people
Calories 121kcal




  • Preheat oven to 350F, and place a silicone mini muffin tin on a large baking sheet.
  • In a large bowl stir coconut oil, butter, sweetener, vanilla extract,and egg yolks. Beat briefly until combined. Mix in chocolate chips, coconut, and nuts.
  • I used a small spoon and got 24 cookies in my mold, or you can use an 8x8 baking dish.
  • Bake 12-14 minutes until light golden brown. Do not remove these for at minimum 30 minutes. They need to thoroughly cool before removing or slicing.
    Keto Magic Cookies


Serving size = 1 cookie*
Each cookie was a Tablespoon size = 15 grams or o.52 oz
TOTAL CARBS = 2 Per Cookie
NET CARBS = 1 Per Cookie
*Seriously you will probably eat more than 1, but the MACROS are calculated that this recipe makes 24 cookies the way we prepared them.


Serving: 15g | Calories: 121kcal | Carbohydrates: 2g | Protein: 1g | Fat: 11g | Saturated Fat: 6g | Cholesterol: 29mg | Sodium: 3mg | Potassium: 39mg | Fiber: 1g | Sugar: 1g | Vitamin A: 93IU | Vitamin C: 1mg | Calcium: 7mg | Iron: 1mg


In this section we try and highlight other Keto recipes that might interest you.  This week we decided to highlight another very popular and easy to make Butter Roasted Pecans.

Butter Roasted Pecans






Interactive keto plans optimized for quicker and better weight loss results. Designed and tested to give results in just 28 days.

    • 200+ delicious low-carb recipes for every taste
    • Weekly shopping lists to stay on track
  • Expert guidance that make your goals a reality

Check out the Keto Academy!  If you want real results on Keto this is some of the best information available.


Cjsketokitchen MerchFat Is Where It’s At
Cjsketokitchen Merch“Fat Eyes”
CjsKetoKitchen MerchCjsKetoKitchen Merch Logo Tee

Affiliate Disclosures 

From time to time we will recommend products and services that we have used, and have found to be very good products or services. We may get a small percentage of a purchase you make, through one of the affiliate links that we included. Any payment we receive is paid to us by the company (not you). These small payments help us to continue to produce keto recipes and other content as we seek to spread the message about the Keto Diet and the health benefits of the keto lifestyle. Thank you for your support, it is appreciated.

CjsKetoKitchen is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to products on


  1. I can’t wait to try these…
    CJ you are so blessed to have Sarah. I love her fancy style. :-). Sarah you are STUNNING girl!!!I’m getting my husband into these recipes. Just dont think they taste as good as yours. You two ROCK.. Keto On

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating